Desnethé-Missinippi-Churchill River (DMCR) is the 7th largest riding in Canada and had the 12th smallest population in the 2001 census, nearly two-thirds of whom (64%) identified themselves as Aboriginal, with an immigrant population of just 1.5%. In fact, after Nunavut and Churchill, MB in 2001, DMCR had the third highest concentration of aboriginal residents of any riding in Canada.
Although adult residents were slightly more likely to be married than single (45% vs. 42%), the riding was among the top 10% percentage of single (never married) residents, and had the 7th highest percent of single-parent families (26%; 20% female-headed), with the number two percent of male-headed single parent families in the country (6%), and the number three family size (3.5).
By religion, 45% are Catholic, 38% Protestant, 13% claim no affiliation, and there are no other groups of note. 34% report a mother tongue other than English or French (with the remainder nearly all reporting English), and that mother tongue is spoken at home either with English (21%) or on its own (another 12%). The riding also records the fourth highest rate of speaking a combination of English and non-official languages in the workplace (19%), although most people work in English only (78%), and just 2% work exclusively in a non-official language.
The education profile of the adult population skews predominantly towards those not having completed high school (at 53%, the second-highest ranked riding nationally), and is among the lowest ranked in completing high school (4th), college (2nd) or university credentials (7th), although it ranks in the top third for Trade certifications.
42% of the adult population is not in the labour force and, of those participating, the riding recorded the 11th highest unemployment rate in 2001 (17.8%). While most reported doing 5 to 29 hours of unpaid housework, the percentages reporting 60 or more hours (14%) and 30-59 hours (16%) were the highest and fourth highest nationally. Thus, in 2001 the riding recorded the second-lowest individual income and second-lowest family income in Canada (and the lowest in Saskatchewan), and was among the bottom 10% nationally in household income.
Most people reported working in Sales and service occupations (21.1%), Occupations unique to primary industry (16.9%), and in Trades, transport and equipment operators and related occupations (16.1%), and although the riding scored highest in Canada in unclassified occupations (6.1%), it ranked 4th lowest in Business, finance and administrative occupations (just 9.5%).
53% of the riding are home-owners, 23% are tenants, with the remainder presumably living in band-owned housing or other forms of land tenure. The average dwelling value of $76,978 is in the bottom 10% nationally.
The seat has re-elected an incumbent Member of Parliament just once (Rick Laliberté in 2000) since it was formed in 1987 from parts of the former ridings of Mackenzie, Prince Albert, and The Battlefords-Meadow Lake. Laliberté had run for the NDP nomination against incumbent M.P. Ray Funk when the riding was called Prince Albert-Churchill River in 1993 and, having lost the nomination, ran as an independent against Funk, likely costing Funk his seat to Liberal Gordon Kirkby. Laliberté succeeded in winning the NDP nomination in 1997, and defeated Kirkby to take back the seat (now called
Churchill River) for the NDP, but then crossed the floor a few years later to sit and run for re-election as a Liberal in 2000.
By 2004, following reported criticisms of his travel spending, Laliberté chose not to re-present for the Liberal nomination and to retire from federal politics. But he later on opted to run as an independent after all, and his 10% vote-share is credited by some as perhaps handing the seat to Conservative Jeremy Harrison, in an election with a historically low turn-out for the riding (47% vs. its usual turnout of 57%-59%). In 2006, the Liberals nominated well-known Prince Albert Tribal Council president Gary Merasty, who defeated Harrison by a margin of just 67 votes in a return to historical turn-out levels, although to this day some Conservatives remain sceptical about the high turn-outs reported in many of the most remote communities where they were not able to supply scrutineers.
The Reform/Canadian Alliance/Conservative raw vote held steady at around 7,000 from 1997 to 2004, rising to just over 10,000 with an incumbent running in 2006. The vote share of the other parties has depended on turn-out, the strength of their campaign (only the Conservatives and Liberals raised and spent close to the limit in 2004 and 2006), and the participation and vote share of independent candidates. Thus, given that by-elections are usually characterizied by low turn-out, one might expect that under normal circumstances the Conservatives would be favoured here this time.
However circumstances have been anything but normal with candidate nominations in this contest, given the controversy that arose over Liberal Leader Stéphane Dion's decision to appoint an aboriginal woman candidate, Joan Beatty, with other local nomination candidates already active in the field (including Dion supporter and Saskatchewan organizer David Orchard, and aboriginal John Dorion). Moreover, Dion's choice of a very recently re-elected provincial MLA also raised concerns about the timeliness of her jump to the federal arena. Local supporters of the other nomination candidates complained about decisions being imposed on them from afar and met to form a breakaway Liberal riding association.
Also new for this riding, and so far as I can tell for the entire country, is the presence of an all-aboriginal slate of candidates by the three major parties (the Green Party announced a young non-aboriginal male candidate, Robin Orr, on the closing day for nominations). In addition to Beatty, who was the first aboriginal woman elected to the provincial legislature and appointed to cabinet, the Conservatives are running Aboriginal RCMP office Rob Clarke, and the NDP has the Deputy Mayor of Buffalo Narrows, Brian Morin. This development can be expected to further up-end any predictions one could make from past voting behaviour, putting DMCR on the top of every pundits' list of ridings to watch on March 17.
| 1997 GE | 2000 GE | 2004 GE | 2006 GE |
|---|
| Lib | 5,994 (28.4%) | 9,856 (41.8%) | 5,815 (29.9%) | 10,191 (41.4%) |
|---|
| NDP | 7,288 (34.5%) | 5,141 (21.8%) | 3,910 (20.1%) | 3,787 (15.%) |
|---|
| Cons/CA/Ref | 6,750 (32.0%) | 7,679 (32.6%) | 7,279 (37.4%) | 10,124 (41.1%) |
|---|
| PC | 1,077 (5.1%) | 755 (3.2%) | | |
|---|
| Grn | | | 539 (2.8%) | 534 (2.2%) |
|---|
| Ind | | | 1,923 (9.8%) | |
|---|
| Oth | | 143 (0.6%) | | |
|---|
| TOTAL | 21,214 | 23,669 | 19,542 | 24,724 |
|---|
| ELECTORS | 37,059 (57.2%TO) | 39,807 (59.5%TO) | 41,216 (47.4%TO) | 42,315 (58.4%TO) |
Labels: Desnethé-Missinippi-Churchill, March 17 2008 By-elections